Imperfect Yet…
Taking Simple Vows

| September 5, 2012

My eyes were wet with tears as I was saying my goodbyes. There were eight of us in total gathering for the last time and the sense of separation I was beginning to feel was strong. Over the course of the past 12 months living together, our group had shared a great deal but as we packed our final things, a profound silence settled over our community. All eight of us moved quietly as we entered our chapel for the last time as novices. My emotions ran the gamut—from hopeful and confused to sad, joyful, and even a little nauseous—when I thought of professing vows on my knees before the altar.

Committing to walk the path of my Carmelite vocation is one of the most terrifying things that I have ever done in my life. It has also been one of the most joyful and grace-filled decisions I have ever made. The complexity of the emotional roller coaster sometimes defies all description, but I imagine it is similar to the journey couples travel when considering a life together. The questions, “Who am I?” and “Who am I going to become?” are subtly lingering in the cacophony of internal dialogue. The Novitiate year for Carmelites is a time when the person discerning life as a sister, brother, or priest tries to put some of that internal dialogue to rest for a time to listen more deeply to God.

It takes time to unlearn the ways of thinking, and it often is a difficult attachment to break. My novitiate year came to a grinding halt when I attempted to answer the “Who am I?” question. My generation, the Millenials, find themselves in a world that offers “freedom” in that a person may choose what identity they want to assume. The Construct-An-Identity generation might be a better label for it, because it seems like at every turn a decision is made about what and whom we want the world to know us as. As soon as we entered into school we heard, “You can be anything you want to be when you grow up!” Our world sets everything at our feet and allows us to choose what labels we want to be known by, most often by what we do. The world of high school is where many of us began to make these decisions about what group we identified with, whether it is the jocks, smart people, or even social outcasts. We carry this into our adult lives when we start working, forming relationships and joining organizations.

Finally, the simple realization came to me that my question had to change. I turned to God finally and asked, “Who did YOU create me to BE?”.
A look at my resume left me in a state of confusion because I realized that I have worked in so many different fields and positions like housekeeper, ranch hand, personal trainer or even restaurant manager. I couldn’t possibly define myself by what I have done. My mind was working overtime trying to understand what my doing meant for my identity, for my being and I found myself in an infinite loop. I felt lost and there were times I danced dangerously with despair. It seems that this is common among many Millennials like me who are coming of age and struggling to find a place in the world.

Finally, the simple realization came to me that my question had to change. I turned to God finally and asked, “Who did YOU create me to BE?” This is a prayer that I knew was instantly answered when I felt a surge of peace, God had merely been waiting for me to get out of the way. The awe and wonder pours over me during the moments that it seems like I am watching the Master’s hand do the work, and I can really only savor it when I remind myself that it is not mine.

I chose to accept the invitation to do that with God. The moment of decision stirred up all the dust in my heart and mind, but I knew the only answer that I could give was “Yes.” My yes was imperfect, but it was my best. I had to accept that as God drew closer, I would become uncomfortably aware of my humanity and that was the only hurdle. The yes to God was a yes to undergo the transformation of becoming as I was created to be, and as with all things, there will be a lot of joy as well as pain.

When I knelt in front of my provincial and offered up my simple profession of vows, I offered God everything. I handed over my fears, anxieties, longings, joys, indeed, my whole being. God took all that I surrendered and will give back nothing but grace upon grace to bolster my humanity. The real sacrifice was handing my will, but it helped me to understand the sheer magnitude of the Paschal Sacrifice, and it strengthened my resolve to follow in path that many Carmelites have walked before me. The question I have left now is, “What’s next?”

James Kinkade
James Kinkade
James Kinkade was born in the Wild West currently known as Wyoming during the Reagan administration. Baptized as a Methodist but growing up essentially un-churched, his adolescent rebellion was spent researching religion and secretly attending Mass. He became Catholic and graduated High School within a two week period and set out to explore the world. He was involved in Drum Corps International for five years while taking college classes and worked the Restaurant and Hotel industries before answering God’s invitation to religious life with a puzzled ‘yes’. He attended Casper College and the University of Utah before finishing his undergraduate degree in Philosophy at Loyola University Chicago. He is currently in Simple Vows and studying at Catholic University of America.

7 Comments

  1. John

    Thanks Br. James for sharing your journey of transformation with us! May God continue to bless you with humility and the abundance of his grace, and may our Sister of Mt. Carmel continue to hold you by the hand to lead you on “the path that many Carmelites have walked before” you. Vacare Deo!

  2. James Kinkade, O.Carm

    Thank you for reading, but most importantly, thank you for your prayers! I pray that she wrap you in her mantle of maternal and sisterly concern on this feast of her Nativity!

  3. Donna Davis

    It’s heartening to read others’ spiritual journeys. As difficult as it may be, they’re designed for us with purpose. Blessings, and prayers, for you on your path.

  4. James Kinkade, O.Carm

    Thank you for your prayers, I can use all that are offered for me! God knows how to handle you and I ultimately, so there is wisdom at every turn!

  5. James Kinkade, O.Carm

    Faith is no cakewalk, but nothing worth having comes easily does it?All of my prayers for you!

Leave a Reply

↑ Back to top

Carmelite Vocation Office
We invite you to join us on the path up Mount Carmel. Walking in the footsteps of Jesus with Elijah and Mary is a wonderful, deeply satisfying life. We welcome you to contact us at any time via the information below.

carmelites@carmelites.net
773-322-1222
twitterfacebookpinterestRSS FEEDInstagram